Community discussion

Anyone else have an absurdly difficult time finding shoes that fit?

Archive date 28 archived replies

Anyone else have an absurdly difficult time finding shoes that fit? I'm around a 7 in length at most, but width is so hard. My feet are way wider than they are long, and then I have the bunion. And if I size up to avoid tightness around my toes, it'll likely be too long for me, and I'll wind up tripping, lol. Even wide shoes are too wide all the way around, and then it varies so widely from one company to the next. But it seems like there's no "perfect fit," so I often have to wear shoes that are too big so they're not too tight in some spots, lol.

Archived from Bunion Support Group. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

28 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

Are you wearing footshaped shoes like Altra running shoes or Topo running shoes? They are designed to be wider in the toe area and more snug around the back if that is the issue you are having. Both of those brands have great trial periods if purchased online, returns are easy. I have both Altra and Topo now (learned about them on this group) and they are so good! I’m buying clothes to coordinate with wearing running shoes - Pinterest has helped for outfit inspiration to wear with running shoes. I’m aiming to strengthen, maybe one day my feet will feel strong enough to wear the shoes from Anya’s Reviews which seem mostly to have less cushion. Anya’s wide toe box styles, that aren’t just running shoes, would be great.

Community comment#2

I bought Altra and they are good 🙂

Community comment#3

I buy sandal with adjustable straps over foot round ankle and on heel - usually Hotter brand.

Community comment#4

O yes ! I most have spent over 600 euro on shoes but none are ideal. Hoka most uncomfortable. Sketchers slip on what I wear most . I also think that X wide does not mean the distance across from the bunion is 😭

Community comment#5

I like Ryka. But I also have a pair that are wide toe box and are wonderful.

Community comment#6

I like my Topos. They come in wide width and it seems they are only wider in the front which is what I need. I do wear an extra sock on my non bunion foot so it stays snug.

Maybe you’ve already tried them, in case you haven’t here is the website for the Altra shoes. https://www.altrarunning.com/ There is a Facebook group where Altra shoe styles are discussed and experiences are shared, it is called

Here is some info on the Topo running shoes in case you’re unfamiliar with the brand: https://www.topoathletic.com/the-topo-difference I hope you find some footwear that works for your situation, check out Anya’s Reviews too if you haven’t yet, she focuses on shoes with wide toe boxes—though many of her shoes aren’t supportive or cushioned enough for some of us I don’t think. But I completely skip my old (expensive) custom insoles when I wear Topo and Altra 🙂

do you have experience with this brand? I haven’t seen reviews for them. Are they all high drop? My feet are loving low drop and zero drop— it takes the pressure away from the bunion area to have the sole all at one level I think. The higher drop seem to put weight in the front of the foot which aggravates the area. At any rate the brand doesn’t seem to be available in my country anyway… what is your experience with them?

I have ordered from Orthofeet and yes, I wish they would make lower drop shoes! I think they are really good if you want a sandal or slide for an outing / dinner / etc, but I would be hesitant to wear all day due to the heel drop too. They fit fine though, and I actually can’t even wear Altras because their toe boxes don’t have enough depth for me.

interesting to hear. I feel like there is interest and demand for more comfortable ladies footwear that check the boxes like with toe space, that are fashionably attractive and comfortable. I’ll keep an eye out to see if orthofeet become available in my area. In reference to your Altra experience, I found a big difference in depth between the Altra Experience Form style and the Altra Paradigm style — I actually love the paradigm but *without* the insole because of the depth! It seems like it varies with the styles too

Altra Paradigm was SO close to working for me. It’s the oddest thing because it looks like it should work on my foot, but I started feeling pressure after a few days with it. I ordered the men’s version of it this week to see if it might work! 😅😅😅

ooh exciting, new shoes on the way! I hope they work for you Katrina! 🤞 I was going to send my Altra paradigm back and then I happened to see someone on here say how they wear their running shoes without any insoles… so I tried it and I am so happy with them- it was really a fluke that I saw that idea. I’ve learned so much on here, it’s helping a lot! 🙂

I thought about doing that too! I overpronate though and was worried it might cause an issue but maybe not? So many variables…

yeah I caught the Paradigm on sale and would only be able to get a larger size at full price so I was willing to try. I probably would have returned them except for the deal on them. I also overpronate. I wore them all day yesterday and I think I like the soleless Paradigms better than my Altra Experience Form and my Topo Ultra Fly— though I haven’t worn the Paradigms for any vigorous hikes - they are my “good” shoes and I’m trying to keep them clean. I’m not sure if I saw the idea of wearing them without the insoles on this group or in the Facebook group called Altra Shoes Fan Page. I used that group for research before I bought my first pair of Altra. There are discussions comparing sizing between styles etc in that group. It might be worth checking for info and others experiences there if you’re trying to find a running shoe that suits your situation. So yeah, if I ever get another pair of Paradigms I expect I’ll try a half size bigger but maybe I’m better off without a sole and staying with the size I have 🤷‍♀️🙂

Welp, they arrived, but I just don’t think the Paradigm is my shoe, but I do have a super tricky foot. Maybe I’ll try the Torin!

I was wondering how you’re making out with your order! It’s wonderful that we have such access to try so many styles with online ordering… but it takes patience doesn’t it? I’ll be interested to hear how the Torin feel when they come too! Fingers crossed for you~

have you tried Topo running shoes or Altra running shoes? They are wider in the toe area specifically. I learned about them through this group and my life is much better since I started wearing them. I have one pair of Topo and just bought a second pair of Altra two weeks ago. They are footshaped which is great. Maybe they would work for your situation? The return policies on the brand websites are good, there is a trial period so you can be sure they suit.

sorry, one more question if you don’t mind! Does this version have soft mesh? I ordered one other Ryka shoe in the Devotion line, and I think the size would fit if the shoe didn’t have such a hard exterior.

← More Best Shoes After Foot Surgery