Following!
Community discussion
Hi everyone! New to this group and I have a few questions. I had an ingrown toenail removed this morning which…
Hi everyone! New to this group and I have a few questions. I had an ingrown toenail removed this morning which was caused by my bunion. My left bunion got worse in the last month due to ill fitting winter boots. The podiatrist suggested I could be a candidate for minimally invasive surgery. 1. Should I consider surgery by a podiatrist or an orthopedic surgeon? 2. Anyone have experience with minimally invasive surgery? 3. Have you used a silicone bunion shield and how well did that work? Thanks, everyone!
Archived from Bunion Surgery / Foot Surgery Support. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).
The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.
Podiatry vs Ortho in USA only 1. Podiatric surgeon trained in last 15 years will usually have a 3 year residency in only foot and ankle nothing else ! ( Yes there are some brief rotations in other areas ) train with orthos and podiatrists 2. Ortho - they do a one year fellowship with one orthopedic surgeon who teaches them the same thing they learned no variety. They do this after 5 years of learning general surgery and general orthopaedic surgery. So they may or may not have seen a lot of foot and ankle work and only trauma not elective surgery like bunions. 3. Podiatry procedures performed typically in residency is over 1500, Ortho is maybe 300 at most as it’s only a year and little variety of seeing other docs. 4. Podiatry can be board certified in foot and ankle surgery but it must be by American Board of Foot and Ankle Surgery Orthopedist’s CANNOT be board certified in Foot and Ankle surgery only in general orthopedics ( this is a big difference) 5. Ortho docs do not have a major focus on biomechanics, Podiatrist’s do! All of this is a generalization and there are always going to be exceptions. I have seen nightmare results from both sides as well as excellent results from both! It is about specific training, passion for work and experience every time...You just have to do the homework. I was taught by both and have taught both.
Interview several surgeons of both disciplines. Look for a surgeon that has a lot of experience and who you are comfortable with. If you have been happy with your podiatrist for other procedures that is also a good sign.
I went with my podiatrist who I had good prior experience with and I knew he was very experienced. So far I’ve been happy but it’s still early (4 weeks).

Community replies
4 in this archive