Community discussion

Looking for advice (especially from any professionals in the group) after I was presented with options at a…

Archive date 13 archived replies

Looking for advice (especially from any professionals in the group) after I was presented with options at a consult today. I had a lapidus procedure on my left foot when I was 23; I am 31 now. This included a second surgery two weeks after the first because the podiatrist felt another screw was needed. My foot never looked quite right after the surgery, and at this point looks even worse than before any surgery was done. I was pain free for years, but over the last year or two a lot of midfoot pain and sensitivity has returned. In August I saw podiatry again (not the person who did my first two surgeries as I live in a different state now) and she said that the bones never fused and the bunion was continuing to progress, and that the largest screw is in an unfortunate position. She recommended hardware removal at a bare minimum and likely re-fusion, but wanted me to do a CT first to see if there was any fusion at all. I was forced to get a second opinion because my insurance changed right after this and the podiatrist I saw in August does not take my new insurance. I saw an orthopedic surgeon today who did new x-rays and described a malunion rather than a non-union, and said that my foot will continue to worsen (this is the exact wording from his clinical note: "There does appear to be healing of the 1st metatarsal base joints. There is no healing from the 1st to 2nd metatarsal."). He gave me three options and said I need to decide for myself what to do and then call him. Option 1 is just removing the hardware and eventually going back for a re-fusion months down the line. Option 2 is to do hardware removal and revision in the same surgery. Option 3 is to do nothing for now. I liked the doctor but the appointment was quite brief, and I'm now trying to figure out what to do. I am understandably somewhat nervous about making sure I make the right choice and use the right surgeon so that surgery is actually a success this time around, and given how young and active I am I want to make sure I get a good result and can have many decades left without needing more work. I am leaning towards option 2 because it doesn't really make sense to me to do two separate surgeries when they can be combined into one, but am interested in feedback. I am also hoping to get pregnant in around 2 years and would like to take care of this before then. I didn't get a photo of the x-rays but here is what my foot looks like from the outside.

Archived from Bunion Surgery / Foot Surgery Support. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

13 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

Coincidentally I made this video today

Community comment#2

Where do you live? I had lapidus on my right foot and it looks like your foot, disappointing. I had binionplasty on my left foot in January and looks good and normal function. If going to NYC for surgery is an option I highly recommend Dr Wong at Tred Foot and Ankle. You can PM me for more info.

Community comment#3

If it’s an orthopedic surgeon is he fellowship trained in foot and ankle? That’s the route I’d recommend. Would HIGHLY recommend at CT scan to confirm fusion or non-union. Hardware removal without a consent for revision fusion is dangerous because if he removes the hardware and it isn’t fused, it will be unstable and could cause serious issues and would need surgery. If it’s painful and not tolerable you should probably have a revision fusion before you get pregnant that way you can heal first before the baby. Getting pregnant and then caring for a baby you’ll be sleep deprived, not well rested and will need to be mobile after having the baby. Don’t want to deal with a possible non-union or post-op complication after the baby is here. If the CT confirms it is fused, an MIS bunion correction would be a minimal pain, high success rate if done by a competent surgeon. If the hardware from the Lapidus stays in place, a Treace Nanoplasty or Sky Surgical MIS bunion plate would be a good option for fixation. Traditional MIS procedures with screws you’d need to remove the Lapidus hardware as it would be in the way and then you’d have large deficits in the bone with 3 screws being removed. Just my two cents. Disclosure, I am not a surgeon but I’ve been a foot and ankle rep for 10 years and have been in thousands of these surgeries. My recommendations are what I would do if it was me or my family member.

Community comment#4

I can’t offer practical help - still treading those deep waters myself. It does sound like you’re going with your gut tho, I think you’ll know with what feels right when you hear it.

Community comment#5

I too had lapidus and big toe fused years ago. Why though would anyone say ok ,I'll let you cut my foot open TWICE? I'd get it all done at once. Sorry your fustion failed. I had all hardwear remove like 4 years ago in hope it would reduce inflammation n it did not. My walking is not the same as is my balance. It sucks. Good luck to you. I hope your outcome is improved and better then mine

Oh 😭 what about the other place he works at, BronxCare Hospital, not sure if hospital takes different insurance than private practice, you could ask.

walking recovery, didn’t have to take prescription pain meds, hardware is fully embedded nothing sticking out or on top of bones, if you’re in NYC it’s worth talking to Dr Wong. His private practice partner Dr Ayoub is also excellent, he actually operated on her feet back in 2020.

No photo description available.
← More Minimally Invasive Bunion Surgery (MIS)