Community discussion

So I have an appointment booked with the podiatrist….

Archive date 74 archived replies

So I have an appointment booked with the podiatrist…. I’m getting my nails removed (x2). The question is if I want to do non permanent or permanent removal. What’s the chances of the fungus growing back if I don’t do permanent removal? I will keep treating the toe with oregano oil…. Should I just go for the slammer and get it permanent? I don’t want to have to go back later and re do it if the fungus grows back because I didn’t get permanent removal…. So hard to decide! Has anyone had a non permanent nail removal and not had the fungus grow back? Photo for attention.

No photo description available.

Archived from Toenail Fungus Support & Management. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

74 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

I'm to terrified to have mine removed. Can't get past the numbing shots

Community comment#2

I just had mine removed, but not permanently

Community comment#3

Your doctor suggested removal? My doctor prescribed a med as the first line of treatment. What treatments have you already tried?

Community comment#4

My daughter has a couple nails removed (not permanent )last year . Knock on wood the fungus has not came back but she did also complete a round of oral medication fot the fungus too !

Community comment#5

If you have the nail removed the fungus will still be there. If you do Epsom salt and the fungus cream, you should do ok with a new nail. When you look at the bed a few days after the procedure, you will see the fungus, it will be little yellow dots. Good luck

Community comment#6

My big toenail grew back perfectly after removal but I think the other nails then reinfected it later. It was perfect for quite a while. That was a couple years ago. I just finished Turbinafine last week and praying I have good toenails next summer!

Community comment#7

Try jubilia

Community comment#8

I had it and did laser treatments. It went away after several treatments.

Community comment#9

I had mine removed in the fall of 2022. I'm just now seeing the smallest dot of imperfections this fall. I will keep having it removed. Living with the ugly nail is just humiliating and having it permanently removed is just as embarrassing. The numbing shots were excruciating, but I'll do it again before it gets this bad.

No photo description available.
Community comment#10

I have been doing oregano with Vicks coconut oil mix and apply . It works instead of the nail removal because you have a risk of the nail not growing back again . Also taking by mouth oregano pills and soaking feet in vinegar with water and backing soda could help eliminate the fungus . Just remember you need consistency 🙏❤️💛

I was terrified too, and it does hurt (there are also different initial shot locations so i can only go by what I had) but it's numb fairly quickly and not bad after that.

the shots do hurt a little bit the problem is when it wears off and you're at home in excruciating pain for a while

I’m always pregnant and if I’m not pregnant there’s always the chance I might be so oral meds is just Not an option for me. I don’t really care what the dr suggests to me I want to make my decision… and I don’t have 30min a day to spend on my nail smh more (applying stuff/sanding it down/applying tinctures).

how long ago? Did you do the treatments after the new nail grew back? And how long was that from when it was removed?

Community comment#26

My question is, how bad does it hurt to have a nail removed?! 😳

Community comment#27

Tree tea oil works

Community comment#28

I got mine permanently removed now I can’t stick a fake toenail on it 🤣

Community comment#29

If you get it removed it will come back

Community comment#30

My daughter had toenail fungus on her big toe. The toenail came off and she hasn't had the fungus since. That's been 12 years

Community comment#31

My Dr won't remove my nails or clean under my nails cause I ain't a diabetic. So for my question I don't wanna change Drs cause he good with cutting my toe nails and file them down . Just bad at cleaning under neith them and getting rid of the fungus etc so how do I fix this or make him remove the nails

Community comment#32

All I can tell you is that I did the non permanent and the infection grew back w the nails so next week I'm getting permanent.

Community comment#33

I had my big toenail removed and they gave me a fungal toenail liquid to apply twice a day and my nail grew back pink and healthy. They started me on oral lamisil but I had an allergic reaction to it so had to do the liquid painted on the toenail but that worked just fine. It’s been 2 years now and it’s still a healthy pink toenail. I’m wanting to have it done to two others that I have too but have to wait for a good time since I will have to be out of work for at least a week.

Community comment#34

It will come back if youre not taking care of yourself. Clean socks, clean shoes from anti sprays, and washing your feet and using your medicine. If this is hard for you consider permanent.

Community comment#35

Mine came back after removing my toenails, when they grew back my fungus was worse than ever.

Anonymous member 222 So it’s grown back and you’re starting to see the fungus come back? Do you treat it? That’s unnerving about the needle hurting eeek

need to find a good nail tech that does pedicures and have her drill off all the yellow and get the fungus eliminator. It has worked for my husband and all his athletes foot is gone now too

I have clients that have had their ingrown cut out and ended up with every toe with fungus. It will take a min to grow out because toes grow slower but the will definitely help get rid of it with all natural ingredients

ingrown? And the tool needs to be sanitized between each to. It’s used on maybe that’s why they all got infected.

Ive done it all and it doesn’t work. I have 8 kids and no longer have 30 min a day for two years now to spend on my nail.

Also you could also take a couple as 2 , 3 drops of oregano oil . Put in juice and drink . Because not only you are applying it , but also I consuming it . It heals internal and external .

they sell organic oregano oil you could apply it directly to the nail or on a cotton ball and put cotton ball on the nail and wrap it with a cloth bandage 🩹

lol I had a big toe nail removed after 5 numbing needles. I still felt the whole thing!!!! It really truly hurts alot. More then trying to walk for the first time after a c section lol.

same but I have nerve damage so numbing agents don't work on my left leg or foot. I eventually told my Dr to just get it done and I'll deal with the pain. And that's exactly what happened

Same with me. I actually pulled it off because it separated from my toe. Grew back and no fungus but I have it on another toe now…and I can’t get rid of it.

Community comment#70

Well i have suffered with the same condition i give you one solution just please make sure that your's nails are dry don not wear socks and closed shoes let them open wear open flaties and slipers

Community comment#71

I don’t understand this model at all. I would not undergo this. It’s trauma for the nail bed and you still aren’t solving the underlying condition. Yes the fungus will grow back on the new nail. I can attest to that.

Community comment#72

thats it hurt?

← More Toenail Fungus Treatment