Community discussion

Who is a better candidate to operate on bunions and orthopedic surgeon or a podiatrist?

Archive date 14 archived replies

Who is a better candidate to operate on bunions and orthopedic surgeon or a podiatrist?

Archived from Bunion Surgery / Foot Surgery Support. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

14 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

Orthopedic surgeon

Community comment#2

I had a podiatrist-great results

Community comment#3

This question has been asked and answered so many times within this group. You’re gonna get a variety of answers based on patient experiences and outcomes. Although I chose a podiatrist for my procedure, which was the best choice for me, I do believe that BOTH are qualified to perform surgery on bunions. A Podiatrist’s scope of practice is specific to the biomechanics of the foot and ankle. An Orthopedic surgeons’ scope of practice is broader, as they treat the entire musculoskeletal system. That doesn’t mean that podiatrists are less qualified. It also doesn’t mean that orthopedic surgeons are better qualified. There have been positive surgical stories from both sides, as well as negative stories. I suppose it depends on the nature of the problem as well as patient preference, in most cases.

Community comment#4

Either is fine as long as the Ortho specializes in foot and ankle. Don’t get bunion surgery from an Ortho who does not specialize in foot and ankle.

Community comment#5

Either, have an appt with each see which you prefer. I am an OR nurse in my experience each are qualified and good at their craft. If Orthopedist I would select one that specializes in feet

Community comment#6

Main thing is to go with who has performed the particular surgery needed the most and get at least two opinions.

Community comment#7

I think it depends on the underlying cause of your bunions and if there are other conditions need treatment. I originally went to a podiatrist but then had to see an orthopedic surgeon due to a tendon issue in my foot. I stopped going to the podiatrist because for my condition-the orthopedic surgeon ws a better fit. I saw him almost 8+ years before actually having surgery. But he saw me thru multiple foot conditions before my posterior tibial tendon failed and required immediate surgery. The podiatrist would not have been able to do my surgery due to the specialization needed for all procedures involved.

Community comment#8

I used a podiatrist that was recommended by my nurse practitioner at my GPs office

Community comment#9

https://www.footankledc.com/.../orthopaedic-foot-and.../219 FOOTANKLEDC.COM Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Surgeon vs. Podiatrist: Who Should You See? Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Surgeon vs. Podiatrist: Who Should You See?

Community comment#10

orthopedic surgeon ... in Canada i dont think Podiatrists can even operate

In Canada podiatrists can operate but its private. If your bunions are bad enough you can get it covered through an orthopedic surgeon if referred by a doctor and approved.

Community comment#13

If nothing else, do like me and read the conclusion. This is from the National Institute of Health which is (at least before fundings got slashed and people got fired) a world leader in science and health.

Community comment#14

I dealt with both doctors who did my right foot. Both surgeries different doctors terrible results, both surgeries ended up to be a fail First surgery-orthopedic 2014 Second surgery same orthopedic hardware removal because surgery was a fail Hardware removal 2015 Second surgery 2024 different surgeon - podiatrist (different opinion since I was still hurting and having issues) Failed surgery, he ended up botching my foot and still in pain. It’s been 18 months since my second surgery.

← More Surgery Complications & Wound Healing