For me it was. I don't regret
Community discussion
Is surgery worth it?
Is surgery worth it? I still have time to back out.
Archived from Bunion Surgery / Foot Surgery Support. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).
The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.
End of 6 week PO. So far so goodš¤š¤
My first one 12 years ago no, I had a quack doctor. I should have known better. But this time, fixing the mess from last and fusing my toe so this wont happen again (bunions can come back) Iām about 5 weeks out and so far better then the first, Iām happy so far. Gotta have a good surgeon!
Iāve had the lapidus procedure and Tailorās bunion removal on both feet. No regrets and itās awesome having normal looking feet!! š£
Was for me, had my right 1 done last may, left 1 being done this may š
, only you can decide whether your bunion pain is tolerable without surgery. I had reached a point where my foot hurt constantly and my severe bunion was affecting my gait which also caused back pain. Now my only regret is that I didnāt have my lapiplasty sooner.
Iām 4 months PO and now very little swelling and I can wear shoes without that awful discomfort. Iām very happy!
See my post from last night. It was worth it for me.
Recovering from my 3rd op on same foot. Foot definitely straighter but still very uncomfortable so I am yet to be convinced! x
Totally worth it for me. And I'm over a year out on both feet
he told me they can come back but theyāre not painful when they do.
how is fusion? i need done
I donāt know about anyone else but my coming back hurt like hell by big toe was crossed over the second toe! Omg
if done properly they almost never come back
like I said I had a quack. I was non weight bearing for I canāt remember how long, and his PT was me going to his office putting my foot in a whirlpool bath and tens machine. My bunion came back with a vengeance and my big toe was crossed over the next and was soooooo painful. Iām probably the worse case scenario but I canāt see how a bunion coming back isnāt painful especially with hardware in your foot and things are moving. So now I fixed for good, Iām also 63, I donāt want to do this again. I canāt wait to do normal PT in about 2 weeks
I'd be hesitant to go with a doctor that is telling you that. Sounds like he's trying to cover for himself in case surgery isn't successful. Finding a really good surgeon with lots of experience is key!
coming back can depend on type of operation done in 1st place and if arthritis becomes an issue later.
as my now podiatrist said no matter the procedure there is always a chance of it coming back just a matter to what degree! I donāt wear heel, never did or anything that squished my toes, mine is hereditary
yes as is mine. Been wearing kumfs/ziarra xw shoes for over 30yrs plus wide sneakers. Never could walk in any high shoes.
BS, pain was as bad as before . Two years later, I was having a fusion.
the first 2-3 weeks it hurt of course, itās surgery. Iāll be 6 weeks on Monday. I had hammertoes fixed also and those hurt still but having the toe fused thatās good, itās numb but was a little still from first surgery
i dream of my toe going straight. now im walking on side of foot and it hurts and balance off. does fusion fix this?
Iām just learning to walk with this, have till Monday in the boot, ask me again next week, but I think so, itās so nice having a straight toe again.
my question is. What about shoes. Since one foot is fixed and you don't need to wear Xtra wide anymore, how does that work?
same for me. My arch collapsed so I stood poorly which caused me hip pain. Wish I did my surgery a long time ago. But thankfully my hip pain and bunion pain are gone now.
lapiplasty isnāt an option for me where I live unfortunately.
yes! The reason has to be pain.
I also have fallen arches from the bunions I assume.
causes alot of issues
others in this fb group have had positive results with other procedures. I hope you get some relief!
do you wear wide shoes? Iām trying to decide on my post op shoe.
I purchased Hoka Clifton 8ās in white prior to surgery and still wear them. Theyāre wider and very comfortable. Also Oofos slides which you can change the width with Velcro. But now I can wear some of my regular shoes. Wore wedges the other night.
It definitely is worth it! Iām 1.5 years on right foot just need the other foot.
I am 12 weeks post op. Not gonna lie, there are a few rough weeks in there, I had excessive swelling...but I am past it and doing well. It's scary, but worth it.
Done 3 times already, not worthy for me
Not getting my feet fixed earlier caused me more problems.
So happy I did! Did mine about 2015 or so if I remember correctly. I did 1 foot recovered and 6 months later did the next foot so I could do the 2nd foot having already reached my out-of-pocket max. I spent a lot of time researching doctors online even looking up complaints to the medical board to make sure I had a really really good surgeon. ļæ¼ I also looked at pictures postop that he had done so I could see the scars that he left on people and literally you canāt see my scars.
Only if causing you pain or severe restriction in function! Mine is disastrous, by a supposedly brilliant podiatric surgeon, 10 weeks ago. Please have a look at the photos in this group.
If you have pain and it is affecting your quality of life, then it is 100% worth it.
I thought it was worth it. I had good outcomes . Iām 6 months post op and Iām cleared to return to running again now. Today will be my first run in about 2 years ! Iām excited and scared lol. I had terrible pain prior to surgery and it was incredibly limiting for me
Your doctor will tell you but in my case oh hell yeah worth it make time for recovery but yes it was well worth it will get my other foot done
Yes. We canāt walked on broken and dislocated toes/feet forever. š
me too , doctor only said I was not lucky ! I was very not happy ! I should tell him he was not skillful!š
If you would have asked me 8 weeks or sooner, iād say no, but iām 12 weeks now , and very happy i made the decision!
Nope, wish I could go back in time
No. Wouldnāt do it again. Not doing other foot.
Yes!!
Mine and my DDās was easy and successful. Mine was a complicated surgery due to arthritis. Kept ice pace behind the knees also at all times to block pain nerve which is a MUST to do.
Itās a b@tch but yes. Long road but no regrets.
I donāt regret the surgery as my outcome, although not perfect, is better than where I was prior to surgery. I would NOT do it for cosmetic reasons, you may regret that decision. And I think a reputable doctor would not support that decision. I would connect with a good doctor and they should be able to help you make the best decision for your specific case.
I hope so. I am scheduled for surgery on Thursday
I am so the same, I feel your indisicion..... So hesitant, keep thinking how bad will hammer toe be in 5/7 yrs if not fixed and then theres the other foot nearly in same position. My bunion so long as Im in wide shoes does not give me grief its the hammer toe that in closed even wide shoes is begining to hurt. Do I wait till too sore Im 71. So many outcomes I see not good, more good outcomes though I'm looking at hardest operation as I have arthritis in toe. Worried about not having movement in big toe after. Just not sure.
I wish I never did it
oh thank goodness...I was having the same thoughts..I'm almost 4 weeks post....been rough for someone like me who's always been extremely independent.
same here approaching week 9 & upto now wish I hadn't done it especially with pins in my toes. š Am walking a bit now so seeing the light at the end of the tunnel. Pins out but don't think I'll ever be able to bend my toes which isn't what I was expecting. Not gonna be good for yoga, running & paddleboarding. Hoping I'm.wrong! š¤
, hang in there! It does get better!!!
thanks for your encouragement! š„°
are you pleased you did it. Did you have any hammer toes involved as well
very pleased. No hammer toe. Would do it again in a second. The surgeon you select is key. Mine was old who has done these hundreds of times. Be aware it does take a year to be fully healed. Some people on her say their surgeon told the different. Mine said a year and that is correct.
mine has already pre warned me. I think I've had enough operations(not related ) which may be part if my hesitancy.
ask your surgeon how many of these heās done which have your issues and if any of those has to be redone and what complications the patient had. Donāt ask āhow many had complications ā nut rather ask āwhat issues and complications did the patients you did haveā. The wording of your questions is key to get answers to ease your anxiety
thank you for that advice
For me it was. Iāve had both feet done (two separate surgeries). Recovery was not without challenges but I would not change a thing. I watched my momās foot problems limit her activity and that lack of activity greatly affect her physical and mental decline . I want to stay active as long as possible and getting my feet Iām good shape will help me do that. My best to you in making the best decision for yourself. š
Iām a few years post op. Iām young, and the pain was already so bad I knew it would only get worse as I aged. So Iām glad I did it while I was young. I couldnāt even wear socks without my bunion hurting, now I can run, walk, wear heels, wear any shoes I want. Only issue is my screws rubbing sometimes but theyāre being removed. Only you can tell if itās worth it or not
The pain before was much worse then the lingering tingling I have 1 year after.
My only suggestion is that you get a second or even third opinion. Can't undo the survey, it can make things worse.
So worth it. I think about things I missed because of my feet hurting and wish I did it sooner.
Go ahead for heavens sakes I had my surgery in 2022 never looked back my surgeon was fantastic. As long as you fully confident in your surgeon go ahead.
If youāre in pain, YES, go for it! Especially if you can manage the time off and have someone to help you out. Recovery can possibly take longer if you wait til youāre older to have it done.
Wish I never had the surgery. Had my surgery 15 months ago. Will not be doing my other footā¦EVER.
You wouldnāt be here if you didnāt need the surgery. Be brave. Be strong. And get r done! I just had mind done on Friday afternoon. Iām doing well. Iām booking my second foot operation on Monday. Canāt wait for both to be done. The sooner you get the surgery the sooner you are on your road to recovery. Take charge of your life. Go for it! Youāll be fine.
I think if I had not had it done, I was setting myself up for a whole slew of other problems. Other problems that wouldāve been harder/more extensive to repair. My dr told me heād rather me do it now (Iām 52) than later. Iām pretty active. So right nowā¦it was the best decision for me.
It wasn't worth it for me, but everyone is different
If you're in pain, yes it's worth it.
All depends on how much pain you are in currently AND if you are willing to stay that way. Iāve had both feet done 6 months apart. Nightmare recovery both times. Iām 20 months post-op and 14 months post-op. No pain in either foot. Go to the gym regularly - no issues. Average about 18,000 steps a day. Happy I did the surgeries but even happier that it is all in my past. 72 years old here. Best of luck to you.
Yes! Year and Year 6 months PO. 58 yo. I should have had surgery sooner. I regret putting it off for years. Find a good, experienced surgeon. Make sure you do your PT. Surgery is not a cure all. It fixes the alignment. You may still be in pain, have arthritis, but work through it because bunions only get worse. I get around so much better now than I did presurgery. My only regret was resting too much. I put on a lot of weight.
why wasnāt it worth it for you?
after the surgery it took 10 months to heal enough and not need another surgery (bone graft and plate). I was having x-rays every 6 weeks and it was a very painful 10 months. 5 years on and I'm in more pain than I was before surgery.

Community replies
78 in this archive