Community discussion

For people with high arches, is there anyone who's worn Hoka's for a couple of years and still likes them?

Archive date 22 archived replies

For people with high arches, is there anyone who's worn Hoka's for a couple of years and still likes them? (Edit to add: can you also please include if you've been wearing hokas for more or less than 2 years? I think that would give me the enough confidence to ditch my Altras, which is what my new podiatrist recommended. I just have so much anxiety about feet because i've dealt with this for over a decade.) I have seen on here people warning that they've tried Hokas, and that even though initially they may have felt good, they've ultimately made their feet worse. And 6 months ago I switched from Altras with a custom orthotic to Hoka's, with no orthodotic, and every time I try to wear the Altras for even one hour (without an orthotic) I seem to have some kind of pain.

Archived from Plantar Fasciitis Talk and Tips. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

22 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#2

I’ve been wearing Altras and still can’t walk for exercise in them. I’m highly considering Hokas so at least I can start walking for a bit of exercise again.

Community comment#3

I just tried altras and within 30 minutes the pain set in.

Community comment#4

High arches and really like my Hoka’s. I walk about 2-2.5 miles a day. I feel like they start to lose their cushion after 200 or so days and they need to be replaced after 1 year. I have 2 pairs in diff colors so I swap them out week to week or so to “extend” their life.

Community comment#5

My Hokas are going strong after 1.5 years but I only wear them for work. Also, I swapped out the insoles for more supportive ones. I have pretty high arches.

Community comment#6

I have high arches and Forefoot Equinus. Hokas are the only thing that dont make my feet hurt. I wear with or without insoles & have different pairs & different sizes.

Community comment#7

I have high arches and also have Hoka, but I prefer Vionic.

Community comment#8

I went straight to zero-drop shoes like Dr. Angela Walk recommends and I was healed in 11 weeks. Altra Paradigm. I still wear them everyday.

Community comment#9

Altra paradigm are the shoes that caused this whole issue for me.

Community comment#10

Love my Hokas. Have three pair!

Community comment#13

Hi ..which type of hokas do people get ..there seem to be a lot of different styles

Community comment#14

I have high arches and have been wearing Hokas for about a year. I’ve always had to replace my sneakers after about a year or less of wear so these are lasting longer than other brands I’ve tried.

Community comment#15

I have been wearing Brooks shoes! And I seem to be doing fine in those!

Community comment#16

No

Community comment#17

Altras giving you pain is most likely you are wearing them for too long. Transitioning is important. If you go back to a cushion shoes and non wide toe box you will undo your work you have done.

Community comment#18

Love Hokas. Worn 2+ years. And with high arches I have been told by my podiatrist a high instep thing in a shoe is more ideal. It throws the weight into your hips more than your calf which in turn alleviates your arch stress.

Community comment#19

I was a big fan of Hoka's The last 3 to 4 years wore them all the time have multiple pairs different colors. Now I'm convinced the cushingness of them is probably what gave me the plantar fasciitis. I've been wearing the Altras and I find them very comfortable.

← More Best Shoes After Foot Surgery