Community discussion

My son is a varsity basketball player.

Archive date 25 archived replies

My son is a varsity basketball player. He started taking creatine and protein supplements in March 2025. Within weeks, beginning in April 2025, he began experiencing significant pain in his shins and under his feet. Around the same time, he also developed a severe fungal infection between the last two toes on both feet. Over many months, his symptoms worsened. We consulted multiple orthopedic sports doctors, physical therapists, and chiropractors. He was diagnosed and treated for plantar fasciitis and shin splints, underwent extensive therapy, used expensive orthotics, took medications, and even had surgery on his feet for the infection. Despite repeatedly mentioning to every doctor that his symptoms began shortly after starting creatine, we were told that creatine is safe and could not be causing these issues. Finally, in February 2026, we met a doctor who immediately recognized that he had Chronic Exertional Compartment Syndrome (CECS). He underwent bilateral surgery on both legs, and during recovery, the doctor asked him to stop taking creatine. During that period, he started feeling significantly better. This week, he restarted creatine—and almost immediately, the pain under his feet returned intensely. After further consultation, another doctor advised him to stop all artificial protein powders and creatine completely, explaining that for some individuals, these supplements may contribute to inflammation, fluid retention, muscle tightness, or other reactions that can worsen symptoms. We were told that dietary changes should ideally have been explored much earlier, before so many invasive treatments. I’m not saying creatine causes problems for everyone. Many people use it without issue. But in our son’s case, the timeline has been impossible to ignore. Please, if you or your child are dealing with unexplained foot pain, shin pain, muscle tightness, or unusual symptoms—especially after starting supplements like creatine or protein powders—take a close look at diet and supplementation as part of the bigger picture. Sometimes the body is telling us something, and it’s worth listening before moving toward medications, expensive interventions, or surgery. If sharing our experience helps even one person avoid the trauma our family has been through, it will be worth it. Edit: This doctor says he treated 4 young patients who came to him with failed kidneys, damaged bones and similar problems. Root cause for all 4 is the supplemental proteins and products. Makes total sense

Archived from Plantar Fasciitis Talk and Tips. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

25 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

What is the benefit of creatine

Community comment#2

That sounds awful, poor guy...

Community comment#3

GIPHY

Community comment#4

Wow 😮 interesting indeed I started creatine after getting PF , I take it for menopause symptoms, and has had no effect on my PF and a lot of positives for menopause. I may try stopping to see if it helps.

Community comment#5

Darren Peterson of KU, heading to the draft, somewhat ruined his college basketball season and messed with his draft stock potentially because he was constantly dealing with cramps. Turns out he was taking waaaay more creatine than he was supposed to causing the cramps. Your story made me think of his.

Community comment#6

Thank you for sharing your experience! Wishing you son complete healing!

Community comment#7

Thank you for sharing. It makes you wonder, how many people have developed PF because of something they are putting in their body. Could even be caused from a medication they are taking. I've read stories here that cutting out sugar & junk food has been the answer for some.

Community comment#8

I just typed this out to an influencer on YouTube…

No photo description available.
Community comment#9

Why did it take you a year to stop taking it?

Community comment#10

I take creatine here and there, but yeah, I’ve heard it’s hard on the kidneys as well and I got plantar fasciitis after I started taking it, but it’s hard to tell what for sure what caused the PF

WhiteOtter6075 ohh then I don’t want. Too much salt does that and it makes my plantar worse. You don’t want to hold more water where there is injury

very good question. In March 2025, my son had started lifting weights in addition to his already intense varsity basketball training. He began taking creatine because we believed it would help improve muscle strength, recovery, and performance—like many young athletes are encouraged to do. At first, we naturally assumed his pain was caused by overtraining and strain on his legs. We had no reason to suspect the supplements. But because the timing felt too coincidental to ignore, I did my own research—including on ChatGPT—and raised the possibility with multiple doctors that creatine might be playing a role. However, every source we consulted—including ChatGPT and several medical professionals—reassured us that creatine is generally considered safe and unlikely to be the cause. So naturally, we trusted that advice and focused on treating what we were told were sports-related conditions. And honestly, teenagers don’t want to stop something they believe is helping them—especially when doctors and even trusted information sources are telling them it’s fine. Unless a doctor clearly says, “Stop this,” they usually won’t listen to a parent’s concerns. Later, I spoke with an experienced doctor from India who immediately raised concern that creatine and other protein supplements could be contributing factors. He explained that these products in some individuals may react differently, leading to complications involving muscles, kidneys, or bone health. He also shared examples of other young patients he had seen with serious issues potentially linked to these supplements. Looking back, I wish we had stopped all supplements much earlier—even temporarily—just to see if it made a difference. We trusted the widely accepted message that these products are harmless, and that delayed us from considering what may have been an important piece of the puzzle. That’s exactly why I’m sharing this now—not to claim this happens to everyone, but to encourage other parents to question everything, observe timelines carefully, and consider diet and supplements as part of the bigger picture before going through medications, expensive treatments, or surgeries.

Every doctor and every source dismissed my observation. This CECS surgery made him stop for last 2 months. Now when he started and then the pain coming bk made it clear yet these Athelets find it hard to believe while so many of their peers growing and building muscles. Thank God this doctor from India confirmed my point.

Community comment#20

So creatine cause PF? I mean there pure creatine and chemical creatine?

Community comment#21

Can I ask if he was taking 100% creatine or was this a mixed bag of ingredients?

Community comment#22

Creatine has helped the pain between my shoulder blades when nothing else helped. I think we must be wary of many protein supplements because of their source (whey, casein, soy, pea, egg white protein) as well as the other stuff they put in it such as seed oils and sweeteners --sugars and/or artificial sweeteners-- to enhance taste. Unfortunately some whey powders also have higher lead levels than the "safety levels". All that said, everyone is different and protein powders vary so what works for one may not work for another. It's always buyers beware. No matter what product/food you take these days you have to read labels as increasingly even food items have been found to contain products not too beneficial for our bodies.

it caused Compartmental syndrome for which he had to get bilateral surgery. Now his foot is also hurting after restarting creatine. Yes Creatine caused so many problems in his lower body. We are completely stopping for life. It’s 100% creatine

← More Post-Surgery Swelling & Inflammation