Community discussion

Need women's walking/everyday shoe suggestions with wide toe box, custom orthotics, I have plantar fasciitis…

Archive date 16 archived replies

Need women's walking/everyday shoe suggestions with wide toe box, custom orthotics, I have plantar fasciitis plus hammertoes plus metatarsalgia (stress fractures in ball of foot) plus previous Lisfranc injury. Podiatrist only gives brand names and that's not helpful. I've been wearing specific types of Brooks and New Balance and want to figure out if these are the right choice. Feet are sore after walking more than usual yesterday. Thanks!

Archived from Foot Pain Community. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

16 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

Hoka, Bondi 8 are the best ever for Metatarsalgia, they are worth every penny, I Thank God for them. Life changer for me.

Community comment#2

Brooks Ghost was recommended by my podiatrist. I also have New Balance Fresh Foam 1080. She told me to buy running shoes not walking or hiking shoes.

Community comment#3

HOKA Bondi 7 cured my plantars fasciitis. They don't make them anymore. They now have Hoka Bondi 8, which my husband wears. I hope you find relief. These foot pain issues are no joke. They're truly life debilitating.

Community comment#5

So sorry to hear that. I still have the original design of Altra shoe that has a wide toe. Almost the same issue as you and what has really helped reduced the pain is toe socks. Get some from Amazon or REI. The ones from REI last longer. The Amazon ones are conversation starters. 🙂 take care.

Community comment#7

New balance 840 vs running shoes x wide with custom orthotics Do you know if you over or under pronate? That is important info to have when choosing a shoe

Community comment#8

Altra Escalante 3. Best shoe I’ve ever bought. I use superfeet in them.

Community comment#9

Shoes update! Thanks for all the advice. I could not follow up on all the suggestions just yet. All my shoes for the past several years are Brooks Ghost and New Balance 880. This week I'm trying out *four* new pairs of shoes and one new set of custom orthotics (picked up yesterday afternoon). Little time to try everything well enough before a trip next week, and I need to decide which to bring. All are wide, I'm wearing custom orthotics with all. I know it's a bad idea to bring new shoes on a trip but also walking a lot in my current shoes causes metatarsal pain so I'm trying to try them all out at home but also I'm sitting at my desk working most of the day. I plan to bring a pair of old shoes as well, and maybe the walking boot cast. Sigh. IDK. I would hate to need it and not have it, but I'm hoping to not need it! 1. Hoka Bondi 8 - very comfortable on the bottoms of my feet so great for the metatarsal issue. The sole and heel seem very substantial but the part of the shoe along the side and above the toes seems thin. The outer edges of my midfoot seem to stretch out the side a little but are fully supported on the bottom. Due to a great return policy I can go on some walks and decide whether these are for me. My legs have been a little sore wearing these since they make me walk a little differently but I think they may be fine. My new orthotics were cut for these shoes. 2. Brooks Glycerin 21 - these had to be picked up from a different location so I just got them this afternoon. They seem good so far, fingers crossed. 3. New Balance 840 - though I was sized in the store, I'm not sure if these are long enough. They cannot be returned or exchanged if they appear worn so I have worn them around the house some and they seem fine. 4. Merrell Bravada 2 hiking shoes - purchased 2 months ago for the trip, wore them for hours on Monday while just sitting, wore other new shoes while walking, and wound up with severe pain on the top of my left foot while in bed without shoes on! This while trying to fix pain on the bottom of my right foot. I iced and took Advil and thankfully it calmed down. I suspect it's these shoes because they felt tight and I put my thinnest orthotics in to try to help but still tight. I submitted today for an exchange for the next size up.

Community comment#10

I use wide APEX and they have a roomy toe box so my socks fit too!

thanks. I have Brooks Ghost and New Balance 880s but idk when/why I might have switched from 1080s so I'm wondering if I need to switch back. I get new of both every year even though I'm probably not putting on the miles they max out at, but still use the old ones a bit as well, not sure how to know when not to anymore. I think with all my problems even wearing these shoes for nearly every step, my feet will continue to be sore. I just want the best shot at feeling ok with increased walking. Why running and not walking shoes?

The podiatrist said running shoes because they have more padding. I’m not a runner so I always wore walking shoes until I bought the Brooks and New Balance. Big step up in cushion, which for me has been helpful.

Also, I have noticed that my foot pain is alleviating as the temperatures start to increase. The warmer weather has been very welcome! I was even able to wear flip flops for a day😊

← More Hammer Toe Surgery & Correction