Community discussion

I have had bunions ever since I can remember, I’m turning 29 in April.

Archive date 28 archived replies

I have had bunions ever since I can remember, I’m turning 29 in April. I have a fallen arch and I over pronate. I have seen 6 foot doctors over the years, 3 sets of custom orthotics made (never helped much). Last visit with an orthopedic surgeon was when I was living in Portland, OR said I need to get surgery to fix the problem. I almost did it, but too scared it would fail and also the recovery time was not appealing. In the last year I discovered “barefoot shoes” and shoes with a wide toe box that allow your toes to splay. I’ve never been able to splay my toes before, but now I can ever so slightly. I ditched the orthotics as I just couldn’t ever find a shoe that could fit my orthotic and foot comfortably. Always too big or too tight. When I walk and stand, I make an effort not to over pronate and lean the weight of my feet on the outside like they’re supposed to. Now, my left bunion I think has actually improved! But my right bunion has really been bothering me lately. Painful to the touch, I feel I may have arthritis in the bunion. Looking for advice on what questions to ask when speaking a surgeon, like what procedures would he best for me? Also, would bunion correction be a waste of time because of the over pronation issue? Would the bunion just return? I’m in the Tyler, TX area if there is a podiatrist you could recommend - that would be great!

Archived from Bunion Surgery / Foot Surgery Support. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

28 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

would like your thoughts as I’ve seen many of your insightful comments

Community comment#2

I highly suggest you look for an orthopedic surgeon. Just a suggestion.

Community comment#3

I would also see an orthopedic surgeon. I just had my second foot done and I think it’s good to to do it sooner than later. I have hardware in both feet. Not sure how the bunion could come back.

Community comment#4

As far as getting the surgery, you'll know when it's time. I can remember going to the nurse in 8th grade because mine foot hurt so bad. I got my foot done last year at 58.

Community comment#5

FWIW, if you are interested in learning more about barefoot shoes and going further down that route, including getting suggestions for exercises to try, I would recommend joining the following group. Also, have you tried toe spacers? Usually big toes aren't going to straighten out on their own as much as they will with toe spacers. The brand I recommend is Correct Toes (google their website) and you can also see posts about them in the barefoot shoe group.

Community comment#6

Foot clinic or east texas. Dr Phelps just did my bunion removal in office two days ago. I really like him. He did state orthotics. I point blank told him I’ve done it all and it’s time for surgery. He’s over on the loop in the same area as Negum and worthington law firm

Community comment#7

My recommendation is in Houston. Dr. Gary Lepow or any of the Lepow family of doctors. My family has been with them for years. My Grandmother worked with one of them. Highly recommended.

Community comment#8

I mentioned this in another post - a fancy ortho surgeon did my mom's bunion surgery years ago and over-corrected. It looked deformed afterwards, but there was little pain so she never had it fixed. After that, I thought if I ever had it, I'd go to a podiatric surgeon who did lots of surgeries - because they are all feet, all the time. Orthos do shoulders, knees, hips, etc. I want a true FOOT specialist when/if I go under the knife!

the way a friend in the health field explained it is they are trained specifically for surgery and that’s all they do ( plus they are an MD with extra years for specialty).

the weird thing is, when I was a teenager / young adult is when my feet hurt the most. Constantly complained about them and I always had jobs where I had to stand 8+ hours. I remember out of high school I worked at a factory with concrete floors and 12+ hour shifts, no sitting. It killed me. Even in my Hokas with custom orthotics. But for some odd reason, after I got pregnant (age 22) and delivered a baby, my feet hurt much less. Even with standing all day long. Not sure if my pain tolerance for higher or if the pregnancy hormones did something to my feet? My right bunion hurts most of the time though, lately. Like even to touch it. Feels like it has arthritis in it.

my foot hurt a lot when I was younger. Went with fashion rather than comfort. Once my foot started hurting all the time, and I was changing my shoes 4x a day at work, I just decided one day I was calling the surgeon.

oh yeah I can agree on the shoes, definitely. I gave up fashionable shoes many years ago, although I do love some Vionics! I only wear “cute” shoes maybe 1 or 2 times a year if I have to go to an event. Other than that, I’m in OOFOS sandals or their tennis shoes.

Vionics are great. I always buy good shoes now (on sale) and I always buy wide. Left foot isn't as bad either so hoping I won't have to get it done.

I did get surgery. I must have had the best surgeon in the world. I really didn't have much. Took the pain meds for a couple of day and stopped because I didn't need any. And I have a very low tolerance for pain. I pretty much just plopped myself in bed and had my foot elevated above heart and iced a lot.

My foot would have been great but I lost my balance getting into the car after surgery and I put my foot down and heard a crack. I ended up breaking the only part of the bone that was intake on my big to. I did fall a few times and I banged it a few times. The outside of my foot hurt way more than the part operated on. It was like a briluise on top of a bruise on top of a bruise. So I had to get another surgery. Which again, did not hurt. But now I have a space like a V between second and third toe which I hate.

would love to look further into this! I have switched my whole collection of socks to Tabi socks, commonly called flip flop socks. I think that in combination with the right shoes has really been helpful!

I agree that socks have an impact, too! I almost always wear toe socks. Toe socks are different from tabi socks in that they have an individual opening for each toe, like gloves for the feet. In fact, I usually wear toe socks with the CT spacers over them in my shoes.

small world! So glad someone in my area has an experience with a doc in my area. What were your bunions like before? How did he do it in office? I’ve been told that the minimally invasive bunion procedures I’m not a candidate for.

this dr was the first who said he could easily do MIS. I like that due to not having hardware. He also shortened on of my toes. I’ll post below some pictures of my right foot. This first picture is my before. It doesn’t look as bad as my left but it is the worse one in the form of pain. I should have gotten it done when I was younger. I’m fixing to be 40.

No photo description available.
← More Minimally Invasive Bunion Surgery (MIS)