Community discussion

In DESPERATE need of a walking/hiking shoe (or boot) – Recommendations Please I have….

Archive date 10 archived replies

In DESPERATE need of a walking/hiking shoe (or boot) – Recommendations Please I have…. Very flat feet. Eternal struggle with finding a shoe that works. Now that I’m older – I also need a shoe with arch support AND cushion. Problem: Most brands only provide one. Arch Support OR Cushion but not both. Called reps from Ascics, New Balance, Hoka etc etc etc. It’s one of the or the other. Hoka shoes DIG into my flat meaty portion where the arch should be (the OLDER speed goats worked – new ones are terrible). I used Ortho Feet for a hiking boot and it’s comfortable enough with thick cushioned socks. I use their plastic inserts to provide arch support. But their walking shoes hurt hurt hurt the ball of my foot (no cushion + live in FL so no thick socks). So – thought of buying a cushioned shoe then adding an insert for arch support (from good feet store) – but then you fall into 2 issues. 1- The “fit” is off and I had to return the shoes. 2- Removing a nice cushioned insert and replacing that with a stiff one to provide arch support almost defeats the purpose – then ball of feet hurt! So – now what? Any advice is highly appreciated

Archived from Foot Pain Community. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

10 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

Hoka shoes! I used to do ortho feet but once I started wearing hokas they’re the only shoe I can wear

Community comment#2

I know this doesn't answer your question specifically but you might find something useful here?: You may need to buy wide or extra wide shoes.? Or maybe "Barefoot shoes" (I've never bought any yet) are supposed to provide extra room inside the shoe. I always add my own hand made instep (I make them with silicone). I don't hike, but I buy super wide slip on mule shoes now (easy spirit) but they are not long lasting nor for hiking so I think I might transition to barefoot shoes - for their supposed roominess. I'm older too. I luv luv luv water filled insoles for the supreme soft impact cushion but one grain of sand will rub them over time and they could leak. But still, they are pretty durable.

Community comment#3

I have Hoka and Brooks. I think Brooks are better.

Community comment#4

Have you tried Sketchers? I find the memory foam work for my flat feet and tender arch. Some styles are a lot better than others, so buy at a show store if possible.

Community comment#5

Best boots for flat feet. Will make your feet stronger over time with consistent use and good walking technique

Community comment#6

See if you have a sport shoe store local that can fit you fit a proper shoe. They are trained to watch you walk and know exactly what type of shoe you need ( to put it simply) I spent thousands and thousands of $ on shoes over the years that didn’t work. This is what finally helped me. Ended up most wide aren’t wide enough plus I needed a stability shoe as I under pronate which I knew but still kept buying wrong shoes.

I tried almost all of them. They dig into my "meaty" flat feet part. Only speed goats worked. Both shoe and boot. The new ones are bad!!! The Olds ones awesome but now are stinky from overuse 😞

I’m sorry that sucks. Have you tried orthotics in them? I have to do hoka shoes with powerstep insoles it takes a ton of trial and error but hopefully you find something that works for you❤️

I want to try barefoot shoes, but are they in stores? I’m envisioning a long process of ordering and sending back, just to try them on.

Mmmm sorry, I'm not there yet, in my research, not sure if they even sell the "Barefoot" brand on Amazon in my country yet (Canada). I need to research that before I buy shoes the next time around. The brand "Barefoot" also sells special socks with rubber bottoms so that your foot stays put inside a wide shoe, which is also an interesting consideration. I think the goal of Barefoot is to allow freedom for all sides of the foot, but you don't want to slip around inside the shoe either. For my specific feet, I would still need toe spacers (silicone) and my homemade arch supports and 5-7 sessions of stretching per day which I'm now learning about too online. And if there is room in my shoe (my day shoes are extra wide mule slip-ons, those gloripus water filled insoles that relieve pain on bottom of feet. I like buying shoes on Amazon to read the reviews, myself. I'm always on the lookout,for extra wide, with softness insides.

← More Best Shoes After Foot Surgery