Community discussion

Just sharing here: Bit the bullet and bought the Brooks!

Archive date 86 archived replies

Just sharing here: Bit the bullet and bought the Brooks! (say that 10 times fast) I included a pic of my large bunion, and was pretty surprised that even in B width, the Adrenaline is wide enough for my bunion and it's pretty comfortable right out of the box. I'm a severe overpronator, so I'm hoping the guardrails will help. I already have the Asics Gel Kayano 31, NB 860 Fresh Foam v13, Hoka Arahi 7 & Gaviota 5, and now this. Thinking to say goodbye to the Asics soon, even in a Wide width my bunion hurts in them after an hour I'm spending way too much money, and it's so tiring trying to find THE perfect shoe. My podiatrist recommended shoes with good ankle support, so I'm going for that. But I'm starting to wonder, maybe it's all about the insoles? Like I can get shoes with the correct uppers (eg wide fit for bunions) and ankle support, but don't have to worry too much about the inside because it'll be ok with the right insoles?

Archived from Plantar Fasciitis Talk and Tips. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

86 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

I swear by Brooks... Next time look up Brooks re-start!

Community comment#2

The brooks adrenaline work for me . Any other brooks don't.

Community comment#3

I have the same shoes with heel insoles in them, lifesaver 💯💯💯

Community comment#4

I know feet are tricky, but i have horrible bunions, regular and tailor on both feet. I also have RA related joint erosion that led to very weak ankles, so pf, tendinitis etc. I can't like without Sole cork inserts. I think it's because I need the rigid support with the cushioned shoes. The cork molds to my foot so the arch is in the right place and it doesn't rub the bunions. There are other brands of cork I've meant to try, but so far Sole for the win

Community comment#5

Looks nice but I would never wear Brooks again but I am going to see if I can get a wide pair of trainers to wear when my feet swell. I love my Asics but they get tight when my feet are swollen

Community comment#6

These shoes were a godsend for me, after buying and trying several different ones. I’m on my feet a lot, and these are the only ones that have given relief.

Community comment#7

I just got a pair of orthofeet sneakers and boots and love them they have a 70 day money back ganttie also

Community comment#8

Which Brooks are they ?

Community comment#9

New Balance 860 much better then Brookside for PF.

Community comment#10

Brooks Glycerine for me after spending a grand on shoes.

I bought my first pair from the restart options a few months back. I was very very happy with what I received. They say gently used... My sneakers were basically brand new!! And they only cost me around 60 bucks!! Instead of the usual 140

thank u! I was looking at sole insoles but wasn't sure about the cork.. I live in a very humid climate and heard they aren't the most breathable. Will go take a closer look, I like the thought of it molding to the foot

these use to be my favorite now they hurt my feet going back to kanyo . I didn’t have PF until i wore brooks adrenaline . It’s been 3 months since i wore them and have been in pain ever since 🤦🏼‍♀️

I would never wear Brooks again. I slipped each time I wore mine and now I'm waiting for an operation to fix my wrist after damaging it after falling.

oh no 🙁 so sorry to hear that..I'm not sure about mine yet, only worn them a few days and not for very long each time. I'm thinking to switch the insoles out for better arch support but so far they're ok. I suppose only time can tell if they're suitable, everyone's feet are different 🙁 seem to be good for some, really bad for others 🙁

I contacted Brooks and luckily I had video proof of slipping it caught it on camera so they told me that they don't put anti slip in their trainers. Every trainers should have anti slip. I told my physio and she said you are the fourth patient this week who has said they slipped wearing Brooks so she said she won't be recommending Brooks to any of her patients ever again. I demanded Brooks give me back the money and they did

I have custom made insoles that I tried for a few days, but ended up taking them out, my feet felt better without them

just went to check it out, aw man haha they look great! Now I might hv to buy a pair, they seem to promise great things 😅 which ones do you have?

I have there sneakers and boots for working at the barn cant remember what the sneakers are that i got them have there hiking boots so dose my husband my mom has there sneakers and sandals and my dad has there sneakers

Community comment#35

You can get rid of that bunion with a fascia blaster. Check out Ashley Black's page. She has amazing tools.

FasciaBlaster®
Community comment#36

I like the look of those!

Community comment#37

I had these they were great

Community comment#38

Did you get the gts adrenaline? Those offer great ankle support

Community comment#39

I bought Altras with wide toe box and bought higher arch support inserts. Things are feeling a lot better.

Community comment#40

NB 880 fresh foam got me through my 12 hr shifts when I had a flare up. Wore them with heel cups for 2 weeks till pain subsided. I wear them now without the heel cups.

Community comment#41

Just landed these. Glastonbury next week so hoping these and my Hoka Anacapas will do the trick this year. I got PF very badly last year and it was godawful. 😵‍💫😬😫🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼🤩

No photo description available.
Community comment#42

I’m gonna try them when I walk my whole right foot hurts and the pain shoots up my ankle only when I’m working and walking eight hours straight on cement floors ☹️ it’s just my right foot that hurts My left foot hurts but not as bad. I think my right foot rolls when I walk. I’m gonna get a foot scan.

Community comment#43

Do Altra

Community comment#44

I have like 5 pairs of Brooks, they are my favorite

so far the 860s have been bunion friendly! Bought them before I got PF, happy to know they're good for PF too thx!

yes, the Adrenaline Gts! Can definitely feel the ankle support, love how it keeps my ankles in. Now to just figure out the insoles part

yes it is zero drop and yes, it’s healing. Slowly, I can now lightly jog on it. I was out of commission for a year!!

Community comment#62

U don't need insoles with hokas

Community comment#63

I just got my second pair today. Same exact ones. And for slides I picked up a pair of Oofos. Yes I’m going broke good Lord !

No photo description available.
Community comment#64

I wear Brooks with my insoles and my feet are happy. They have the wide option and that's what I buy.

Community comment#65

I have the same ones and love them

Community comment#66

Had the worst experience with the Kayano. .also no consistency year to year with them. Given up on those

Community comment#67

Only pair I can wear.

Community comment#68

I have a question. Do you all rely soley (pun not intended) one shoes to relieve your PF or do you do daily exercises to eventually not need to wear the PF footwear?

Community comment#69

Ghost Max and ASICS pure gel are miracle workers for me

Community comment#70

These tore my feet up with insoles and without insoles

they are Hoka Bondis. Loads of research, this page and other sources say they help so I thought I would try them. They are definitely very easy on the foot. Am also stretching the feet, lots of stair stretching, castor oil with frankincense and will try taping as well. The pain was awful last year so doing what I can to avoid that this year. There will be painkillers involved but they didn't seem to work last year. 🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼 for a pain freeing year.

yes realised with my arahis my feet don't hurt that much (yet).. Hoping the Gaviotas will work as well when they arrive

yes oofos! So bouncy haha.. And YES holy cr*p these things are expensive and it's all about trial and (costly) error..

the store didn't have wide 🙁 but surprisingly the B width in this is wider than my Asics' Wide haha, not sure what gives

Oh I order online directly from Brooks. Then you get a 90 days guarantee to wear it and can return if they don't work out. I purchased Ghost and Ghost max wide option.

I realise the insoles aren't great for my arches 🙁 but perfect when I switched them out and put my own insoles in! The guardrails feel so cozy haha

me tooo I'm so disappointed, I thought I'd found the perfect shoe at first, but even after just a few mths, I can't walk more than 1+ hour in them before my bunions hurt and I start to compensate, then my heels start to hurt 😕

yeah. I can only wear Birkenstocks and Hokas really. Crocs if I'm not flaring. The Oofos I wear after jogging but I find I can really walk a lot with them..very soft but not supportive

I definitely do the daily exercises as well, I don't want to keep feeling the pain when I'm not wearing shoes/sandals 🙁 massage ball, massage gun on the calves, toe curls, foot stretches, heel raises...

← More Best Shoes After Foot Surgery