Community discussion

Never thought I’d be joining a foot group but here I am looking for some opinions!

Archive date 37 archived replies

Never thought I’d be joining a foot group but here I am looking for some opinions! I’m 25 years old with 2 young kids (2&5) with very flat feet and a very sore bunion!! I’ve always been flat footed but the bunion along with the pain has been increasing in the past 5 years. I saw a podiatrist a little over a year ago who, after doing X-rays, recommended custom orthotics (which I couldn’t afford at the time) and toe cushions, exercises and a brace to wear at night. I’ve been doing that for the past 18 months pretty much every day. The cramps I get in the sole of my feet after removing the space savers at the end of the day are insane. I use a tennis ball to roll out the cramps but I’m not sure how much more I can handle. Since it has been over a year I need a new referral to see the podiatrist again, however I’m going to ask for a second opinion. Long story short my question is, if it’s recommended, should I have the surgery sooner rather than later (or at all)? I do have a job where I am required to be on my feet for %80 of a normal work day, however they have already told me I would be accommodated for.

Archived from Minimally Invasive Bunion Surgery. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

37 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

My advice would be the sooner the better, I put it off for years and ended up getting arthritis in my big toe...I had my bunion surgery this morning

Community comment#2

I agree with Cori Weiner.. Invest in good shoes. I would skip the spacers, but massage and stretch stretch your feet. I think the spacers are doing more harm than good. I've had bunions almost all my life and put off surgery until now. ( I'm 72) I had a child to raise and was an art teacher for 40 years.. always on my feet.. It never seemed to be a good time. You have 2 young children and a job that need you. I think you can buy time by buying good quality shoes that fit you correctly. It made the world of difference for me. See if you can find a store near you that caters to people with problem feet. They will measure you correctly and make recommendations. Google " shoes for bunions" that will give you an idea of brands, styles and prices. I waited for years and finally had minimally invasive percutaneous bunion and hammertoe surgery last week. Good luck to you!

Community comment#3

My surgeon said there is no cure for bunions, only surgery. I've had mine for years and hopefully will now go for surgery in the summer. I take sour cherry juice, helps with the inflammation. It has to be sour cherry juice from health food shops. Not sure where in the world you are!

Community comment#4

It depends on a few factors, including how much pain you are currently having. The bunions do worsen with time. Wearing the correct shoes definitely helps, but overall it is a matter of dealing with the pain or having surgery. I work in healthcare and saw extreme cases and did not want to wind up like that, so I chose to have it repaired before minimally invasive was no longer an option. I just had my surgery last week and so far happy with the results. I'm looking forward to hopefully no more pain to deal with long term.

Community comment#5

I also have very flat feet - and a ridiculous bunion which I inherited from my mother who had bad feet (thanks Mom!) Just turned 60 (don’t tell anyone b/c I’ll say I’m 40, 30 whatever works) and now I really wish I had the surgery when I was 25 … I may be doing it in the next 6-12 months- still trying to find right doctor/procedure.

Community comment#6

Can you get over the counter inserts for your shoes ?? My orthotics help so much and insurance covered some of it. If you can I would get before surgery. My doc said try everything you can before surgery. I am now contemplating because of the pain also ! Best of luck ! But I agree…. When the pain gets bad and you’ve tried other options surgery is probably on the horizon 😞

Community comment#7

Good quality, wider shoes, orthotics (ask to self pay for better a price), big toe spacers, and even acupuncture can help to slow the progression. This investment is so worth it. 10 years ago I thought I couldn't afford orthotics, now I'm really paying a price, and will need bunion surgery.

Community comment#8

Wearing spacers caused my gait to change and ended up breaking my metatarsal. I am now looking into surgery for the bunion.

Community comment#9

I wear Altra brand shoes. They have a wide toe box and are very very comfortable. They’re expensive but If I wear them I don’t have bunion pain, so it’s worth it.

Community comment#10

What shoes do you wear ? You can buy time with the right shoes

did you have surgery now? I am in the same boat you are and was also a special Ed teacher. I am wondering if seniors can heal well from this type of surgery🤔

Linda Mello-Teta yes..I had the surgery last week.. Feb 8. I'm in Phoenix, AZ and heard about Dr Ettore Vulcano a few years ago when he was in Mt Sinai in New York. I had seen several other orthopedic doctors over the years and couldn't see myself being non weight bearing for up to 3 months. I decided to call Dr Vulcano last spring and found out that he now at Mt Sinai in Miami. After speaking to his staff, I set up a Telemed visit. Dr Vulcano faxed his orders to my primary care doctor who sent them to the imaging center. I didn't know if I would be a candidate.. between my age, being 25 lbs overweight, and having osteopena.... oh and being a couple of thousand miles from him.. He instructed me to start taking 5000 mg of Vitamin D. I was also concerned with blood clots as I had 2 flights( 5hrs total) to get back home. He prescribed Xarelto to prevent a clot. We flew home Feb 11. I will have a telemed post op visit with him on Feb 28. He never expressed concern with my being a senior. I know he's operated on some challenging patients including a gentleman who is about 80. It's amazing what can be done these days.. I'll keep you posted!

Annie Castelnovo-Mcmullen My favorite brand shoes are Waldlaufers. I also have Aetrex, Aragon Alegria, Drake, Oasis, Hallux, P.W Minor, Dansko. Jambu and Kiera. I live in Phoenix and try to stay cool, despite my ugly feet. I discovered Jambu fisherman style from Costco and they've been my summer go to sandals. Revere and Kiera I wear for a dressier occasion. I discovered Foot Solutions stores and the Walking Store that carry stylish shoes for problem feet. Foot Solutions even stretches shoes free of charge to accommodate bunions. I used to wear Clark's when I was teaching, but switched to these brands when I found Foot Solutions. I will take pictures and post them for you. ( I have to figure out how to post them)

good luck with your healing🙏🏻 Do you know why he told you to start 5000 mg Vitamin D daily? Also what made you chose this doctor and which type of foot procedure did you have done? Thanks again for responding💕

The Vitamin D will help build up the bones in the feet. I had asked him about calcium and he said it wasn't necessary. After the surgery, he told me to take Vitamin C and B12 Complex. As to why I chose him... several years ago we saw him on TV discussing percutaneous bunion surgery. that was the first time I had ever heard on minimally invasive bunion surgery. I was impressed with his credentials. Many of his patients fly in to have him operate, then fly back home.( like me) He heads up orthopedics at Mt Sinai.. You can find his Facebook page.. also ettorevulcano.com. and also on YouTube.

Linda Mello-Teta I'm feeling pretty good. Occasionally, the top of my foot is sore, but nothing that warrants taking any pain pills. I've only taken Ibuprophen, a handful of times, the same goes for Extra strength Tylenol and only 3 pills of a prescription medication. I also had a pain catheter they inserted in my leg that lasted 2 days. I was able to painlessly remove that on my own.

Francine..I am older as well and contemplating bunion surgery - what type of shoes did you wear prior to your surgery? I would love some suggestions of brands at least -- and do you ever wear sandals? If so have you found a few brands that are good. Maybe a few photos of what you have found comfortable. Would so appreciate it!

Oh my goodness Francine thank you ever so much - photos would be wonderful if you could post some. I am in Rhode Island and we do not have many good shoe stores here that carry numerous brands - I have found the Walking Company but have never heard of Foot Solutions. There are so many more shoe stores out "west" - Colorado, Arizona, California - it may make sense that I take a trip out your way. I will look up the Foot Solutions store as well. I have friends in Prescott whom I have not seen in some time -- just might make sense to come out ! If you can post photos I would surely appreciate it - I am very much trying to avoid surgery as due to the osteoporosis (I am only 65) and being off the foot post surgery there is a high likelihood of disuse ostepenia/osteoporosis which will only lead to a higher possibility of metatarsal fracture when I would begin to weight bear. I am not in terrible pain so I think shoe modifications and a good shoe would be so beneficial.

My favorite Waldlaufer shoes are the powder blue pair and the black pair on the left.. The sandals above with gold and brown leaves are Keira.. very comfortable. they have insoles that are removable. the leaves kind of camouflage my bunions... the sandals in the center are Revere. They include matching extenders to accommodate my bunions... they are very comfortable! the gray sandals in the back are Jambu..I bought 4 pairs under $20. a pair from Costco.. they carry them every summer.. so comfortable!.. wedge sandals on top right are Hallux and the bottom right are Drakes( they tend to run narrow)

Oh Francine thank you so so much.. I love the Waldlaufers and also the Kiera and REvere - I like that the Revere have an insole that is removable as well. I am definitely going to check some of these out - can always order on line or from Foot Solutions or Walking Company or Zappos if I cannot find similar in any nearby shoe store. I so appreciate you taking the time to post these -- gratefully, Annie

all these shoes are so expensive, but I find I get some great bargains by stopping at Foot Solutions when I'm in the area and seeing what's in sale... it gives me a good opportunity to try out a brand..I Got my Waldlaufers on clearance for $50. a pair.. and they're my favorite walking shoes.

Community comment#29

Following and looking for shoe recommendations!

Community comment#30

Ask a doc

I have the Altra Paradigm- it was recommended to me by a Podiatrist and so far the best shoe for my bunions. I worked as a nurse for many years and these shoes were a lifesaver!

← More Minimally Invasive Bunion Surgery (MIS)