I was told that they determine it by many factors including our lifestyle. I was given a lapidus because of the severity of my bunion and other issues with my foot. Was told since it involves a fusion that it has the lowest reoccurrence rate of the bunion coming back. My doc does not do mis. The doc I first saw does do mis though, but still recommended a lapidus for me. So I went ahead and had that. I’m very happy. I had my left foot done last year and my right foot done last month. I would bring any concerns you have up to your doc and discuss. And you can always get a second or third opinion if you feel differently about things.
Community discussion
My podiatrist has scheduled me for a lapidus bunionectomy and I am concerned that she chose this option for…
My podiatrist has scheduled me for a lapidus bunionectomy and I am concerned that she chose this option for the wrong reasons. I've been seeing a lot about the MIS. Can anyone advise which surgery is best for which types of patients?
Archived from Bunion Surgery / Foot Surgery Support. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).
The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.
I had a minimally invasive lapidus. If you don’t trust your surgeon then you should find one you feel comfortable with.
I had a severe bunion and had a mis double osteotomy. There are definitely some benefits to the mis. However, I don’t know how the determination is made. Just for your own piece of mind I would find a dr who does mis and go in for a second opinion just to see what he/she says. That way you aren’t left wondering.
Both procedures can be done for almost any procedure, but the lapidus typically has a more significant recovery 
I had MIS (20 holes!) for 4 osteomies, akin and scarf, 2 pins, along with a ton of tendon/ plantar plate work). I wanted as much function as possible from a deformed foot.
I had this surgery about 18 days ago, I’m 34 and classed as ‘young’ too, They said it’s was best to have to stop re occurrence, due to being young and active. I had 2 weeks in a cast no weight bearing, then into a boot and I can alot more now! The pain hasn’t been as bad as I imagined
Any pic of your bunion?
I'm no doctor but it looks mild to me. I had MIS on both feet with a hammertoe correction on the right too. This was my right before surgery
Left just out of cast & staples 6 weeks with a boot & crutches
would you be willing to share any of your before pics? Specifically any X-rays you may have?
I had a lapidus ( fusion of the 1st MTP joint that was fixed with plates and screws , plus had my second toe straighten fused ( it doesn’t bend at all but doesn’t affect my walking .. I also had my plantar plate done as well and my surgeon preformed that on the ball of foot to fix .. My bunion was severe and caused my second toe to shift and then the plantar plate to tear after many years of walking on it so I had a severe floopy foot with no structure so after years of putting it off it was time .. I was 64 at the time and very active with two walks a day, gym a few times a week and daily weight training .. I am now 1 year post op and I am happy with my outcome , I’m not going to sugar coat it as it’s a journey which every one needs to know , taking one day at a time one step at a time and have patience with your self .. I have had some hiccups along the way with my Achilles tendinitis, and posterior tibilas but months of exercising and stretching has gotten better , no more ankle pain ,. and I work out every day and do two walks, weights, fit back into all my shoes, sandals .. I am glad I did it as no more ball of foot pain or second toe pain .. I had a great orthopaedic surgeon who specializes in foot and ankle reconstruction and so thankful for him to studied the best approach for my surgery .. my recovery was over 3/4months but still after that I was dealing with some swelling.. But I had both drs say it will be up to a year to fully recover from foot surgery .. 💗
Now ( this was around 8/9 weeks
Now
before:
and here’s a standing one:
click my name and you can also scroll and see my other pics. I don’t have very many before x-rays, im sorry 😩
This is my foot and X-ray, I am mostly wondering if mine is severe enough to need a lapidus. I know I should trust the doctors recommendation, but I'm overthinking after seeing so many horror stories and people saying that the recovery is the worst after the lapidus in comparison to others
your feelings and apprehension is completely valid. I do not see a problem with pursuing a second opinion. Recovery is long. But I did not have pain at all. Not everyone is lucky to not have it though. I stayed ahead of the pain with pain meds and a nerve block so who knows if I would have had any anyways. is an established member who also has had a lapidus performed. She can give you excellent advice as well.
I also want to add, it’s important that you’re confident and are comfortable with your decision on which type of surgery to go with. So I think it’s best that you do bring your concerns up to your doc. Ask them why they would perform lapidus over the other and look at their reviews ofc. Seek out a secondary opinion. I had two before I decided on the lapidus. Do your research on which one to go to and if your second opinion says mis, get a third opinion, so you don’t have to chose between the two. It’s difficult for me to make that answer on which one would be best because unfortunately im just a mod, not a podiatrist or orthopedic surgeon, so all I can give you is advice and what I would do if I was in your shoes 🫶🏾 Lapidus may have a low reoccurrence due to a fusion at the root of the problem and is often used when there is instability in the foot and/or hyper-mobility that a mis cannot handle, however, recovery is longer. Mine is much longer because I had two other procedures alongside my bunion correction. Check here and look into the bunion community on Reddit. Do your research and make sure to be fully confident in your surgical choice 🩷 Just like with any other surgery, there are risks and make sure you’re aware of them and that things may not go as planned or that surgery may fail.
I had a Lapidus bunionectomy. My recovery was easy and painless.. I had no issues and my foot is so much better now. My doctor told me he could go the minimal route but that it had a higher chance of the bunion recurring and then I'd need surgery again and that the Lapidus bunionectomy gave me better odds in the long term of things..I was only 33 when I had my surgery (May 2024). So my age was a factor, he considered my job (on my feet all day), my general activity (wasn't much at the time outside of necessity because my foot hurt sooo bad just to even sit on the couch), etc. Everyone is going to say something different but my experience was a good one and I'm happy.
My before x-ray
Before barefoot.
My foot was so similar (slightly worse) than yours. Your results are incredible! I don’t think mine will look quite so pretty - but I’m excited for a similar happy outcome!
I remember your foot. I’m waiting for updated pics!
💙💙 it will not be as pretty as ’s! Bandages come off Wednesday I hope. They are filthy and ragged since I walk so much in the ortho shoe. 🤣
I hate that the recovery was so long, but was told it’s best to get it the youngest I can. I originally only came in to get the bunion fixed but he said let’s just fix everything else wrong with your feet while we’re at it 😩 So I guess my 20s was the best time 😅 I wanted a mis so bad, but both my doc and my first opinion said no /: Apparently, they’ve collaborated with docs from other health plans and noticed that there’s been an influx of people coming in complaining that they had to get revision surgery from mis years later.
when I was in the office, she seemed super knowledgeable and calming. I trusted her fully until I got on here and read so many stories and now I'm wondering if my foot issues match the surgery she recommended
What is your specific concern? We all have different issues so you can’t compare apples to oranges. As far as I understand, the lapidus has one of the highest success rates. I will be having one on my other foot in a few months.
what are the benefits to getting the lapidus? My doctor said that she recommended it because I'm only 25 and she thinks it will come back with other surgeries.
any surgery can come back doesn’t matter what kind you have it just depends but I don’t know if there’s a benefit. I think if you have a relatively normal foot that’s not flat most point in procedures won’t come back. I personally do a lot less lapidus than I used to doing much more Mis now 
Hi Dr. Bregman, I saw your post on here and thought I’d ask about allergies to screw materials. I had an IUD in my twenties and kept having infections because of it. Would I be at risk of reacting to the screws in the bunion surgery because of how I reacted to the IUD? My surgery is this Wednesday.
is there more chance of recurrence if you have flat feet?
yes
I don’t think so, but it never hurts to get tested prior by putting some metal on your arm and seeing how you react to it there are alternatives that do not use metal 
good to know. Thank you.
do you have a before picture of your foot or x-ray pictures?
















Community replies
44 in this archive