Community discussion

What do you all think causes bunions, and what do you think caused yours?

Archive date 63 archived replies

What do you all think causes bunions, and what do you think caused yours? Mine aren’t bad, I only really noticed them in spring 2024 when I got PF. In healing that, I’ve also been trying to correct mine with toe spacers. I wear them most of every day. But with a pic if possible, what do you think caused yours?

No photo description available.

Archived from Bunion Support Group. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).

Community replies

63 in this archive

The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.

Community comment#1

The bone on the side near the curve actually starts to bows in and causing the bottom of the big toe bone to push out. Therefore only surgery will correct.

Community comment#2

What is PF?

Community comment#3

This is nothing

Community comment#4

I’m not sure if you have had children, but my foot doctor said that can cause bunions. Also, they can be inherited. My mother had bunions.

Community comment#5

I was told that it has to do with the structure of your foot and it's tendons. Mine are most definitely inherited.

Community comment#6

Mine are genetic. My mother and grandmother had them.

No photo description available.
Community comment#7

It’s is categorically deformity

Community comment#8

Genetic.

Community comment#9

Definitely genetic. People used to say the cause was wearing tight shoes. Never did that in my entire life. Thanks for the deformed feet mom.

Community comment#10

Genetic. My mother and grandmother both had them and surgery.

I understand that, but what causes that to happen? Is it always shoes that you wear? Cause I pretty much lived in sneakers. I wear the toast spacers. I’d love to correct the bunion, but I’m also happy keeping it from progressing.

agreed. Compared to the pictures I’ve seen definitely. But they are sore sometimes and I’m trying to keep them from progressing.

if they are bothering the person they are an issue. I am assuming she is younger and asking what could help so she doesn't have to have surgery. I am the only one in my family who has had surgery for it and just recently. I am the youngest. I thought I was making a bigger deal of mine until the podiatrist took x-rays and told me mine was severe. I haven't even let him look at my right foot yet lol. I won't be doing surgery on my right foot unless it becomes like my left foot. I am only a week out from surgery on a very severe bunion and hammer toe surgery. Maybe in a year I will feel differently. I wish there was a FB support group when I was growing up and could find things out. My mom was in her early 50s when she had surgery on hers. I have a love hate relationship with my feet lol I tell you though, I wouldn't wish bunions on anyone!! Okay well there is one person who crosses my mind but I still wouldn't lol

I can’t argue, I’m totally open to any ideas. I wonder why do women get them and not so many men? I assumed it was the unnaturally shaped shoes.

, I’ve had two also. I guess while pregnant your tendons/ligaments can relax and become deformed? I’m not sure.

, the first time I went to my foot Dr, we had this conversation.. I said, is it because I was wearing shoes that were too small. That’s when he told me about women and pregnancies. Who knows, it kind of makes sense.

Community comment#25

Low B12 for me. My right foot looks like yours. Big toe and bunionette. Are your feet painful? Any nerve pain. Do you know if your B vitamins are in optimal range?

Community comment#26

Genetic - female line - arthritis and Achilles tendon problems

Community comment#27

Genetics 🧬

Community comment#28

Genetic defo my mum and her mum my nans are very bad c

Community comment#29

My podiatrist said I am hypermobile. I took ballet and wore toe shoes, wore pointy heels at work, and one of my feet is 1/2 size bigger than the other. That's the one w/the bunion.

No photo description available.
Community comment#30

It is very difficult for doctors to permanently fix a deformity that is created as a result of genetics or the way you walk, because it will continue to reoccur. The shoes you wear can also cause deformities. This may be why revisions keep happening. I have had 4 revisions in 47 years due to cerebral palsy, a movement disorder that affects my gait and mechanics of movement. I am a wheelchair user. My hips are turned inward. My left leg is longer by a half inch and drags, creating bunions and hammertoes that reoccur and require surgery.

No photo description available.
Community comment#31

Yours look great. Mine are caused by poorly constructed feet. Very high arches and abnormal walking. Also I had severe scarlet fever which has a tendency to weaken structural support to joints

Community comment#32

Genetics, foot injuries, ill fitting shoes, inflammatory disease etc. I have all the forementioned. My left foot was far worse than my right foot. I waited until I was 61 to have surgery when my left foot could no longer fit in any shoe comfortably. There are things that definitely can make them worse sooner. If you are a woman and wear high heels and are on your feet a lot that can add to it. Improper fitting shoes in general. I wore orthodics, toe separators, comfortable fitting shoes etc. With age they kept getting worse. I got hammer toes also ugh. I know I wore special shoes with foot braces when I was younger and I am sure that had something to do with it. Unfortunately, my parents are deceased and I can't ask why I wore special shoes with foot braces.

Community comment#33

I think that this is a very good question and worth researching.

Community comment#34

Genetic… almost everyone on my mother’s side of the family… including some men have them ..

my B vitamins are good, but I think I’ll get in B12 just to be sure they stay that way. I do eat a heavy meat diet.

if you’re deficient in B12 it can cause muscle weakness in the legs and heels which can alter your gait which can cause bunions to form. Which is what happened to me, and worse. My B12 was so low I got horrible nerve pain/neuropathy as well. I finally got diagnosed with not being able to absorb B12 and need B12 shots. You can google B12 deficiency and bunions to find more information. Do you have nerve pain?

I would say sometimes, not sure whats going on at times, I put it down to dehydration, take magnesium, lack of sleep. All I know is my bunioned foot has been so painful, when I use a toe separator it seems to make the ball of the foot extremely painful and my hammer toe-just looking at how I can work on this as non invasiviely as possible!

oh my goodness! Big hugs! I don't think I could do this again. I am only one week into recovery after surgery and ugh. I had no choice left but surgery. You sure have been through a lot.

I was not able to do activities of daily life like transfer from my wheelchair to the toilet or the shower without my foot hurting terribly. So I needed to get it done.

No photo description available.
Community comment#49

Mine may be inherited. Plus I have flat feet and pf. I just realise last month my big toes leading to second toes . Am wearing toe spacer and I feel better in walking . But heard it cannot slow progress . What kind of toe spacer do u use , is it all toes or between two toes ?Do u wear it in shoes too ?Am in low spirits , hoe do u stay chin up about it ?

Community comment#50

I think because I'm a runner but sir it looks like you also have hammer toes I got the surgery I'm happy I did 😃👍

Community comment#51

GIPHY

Community comment#52

Genetics for me, sigh I also have hypermobile Ehlers Danlos (also genetic) so my joints move where they're not supposed to. My bunions aren't bad right now, so I'm trying to keep it that way. My DR said he would not operate unless it got way more severe. Because of my connective tissue disorder, the chances of the bunion reoccurring after surgery is almost a given 😭

Community comment#53

Why do they call them Bunion sounds so 🤢 gross

Community comment#54

Scoliosis

Community comment#55

Shoes were definitely the cause of mine. Even wearing trainers for years and throwing out anything with a heel didn’t help. I now wear only barefoot shoes and boots, they naturally have a wide toe box too. While not a cure, my feet have been relatively pain free since wearing them. They do take a good few weeks of getting used to though but it’s worth it.

Community comment#56

Definitely genetic !

leena3030 I got rid of my plantar fasciitis by following a couple of people on YouTube and a lady here on Facebook. If you want me to hook you up, let me know. It took me about a year and a half to get rid of the PF, but it’s totally gone. If you do what the podiatrist says, you’ll never get better. That’s regarding PF. I don’t know about bunions for sure. I will link the spacers I use here, and yes, I do use them in my shoes, and I do believe you can halt the progression. These are the spacers I use, and in the space between the big toe and the first toe I put one of those silicone individual toe spacers to make a bigger space between those two toes. Let me know if you want a picture. Jalopink Silicone Toe Separators,... https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GKP2STQF...

leena3030 also, in learning how to fix the PF, I learned that we need to wear shoes that have a wide toe box and zero drop. I transitioned to WHITIN shoes that I get on Amazon and they’re only about 40 bucks a pair.

← More Hammer Toe Surgery & Correction